With Amato's Passing, Middletown Loses Downtown Champion

Reader: The eponymous owner of Amato's Toy and Hobby was an uncompromising voice of common sense and a citizen — in the full meaning of the word.

Editor's Note: Author Jennifer Alexander, co-founder of the and of KidCity Museum, allowed Middletown Patch to reprint this article, which first appeared in the Eye on Aug. 11.

I was proud to call Vinny Amato my friend, but it’s not something I could have predicted. He was 40 years my senior, a businessman and a Republican — I was a alum who’d stayed in town, a self-professed do-gooder and activist. If we were in Congress, we would have been on opposites sides of the aisle.   

Instead, in Middletown, we found ourselves around the same table — united by a love of Main Street and a belief that it offered a unique stage for the individual to create something lasting and worthwhile.  

On committees, at Chamber meetings and running into each other on Main Street, I often heard Vinny’s views on how we could protect our downtown from decline. He started each month with a Thursday morning meeting in the Chamber basement, discussing collaboration between the business community and the city. 

He worked to create a special taxing district, so that the businesses themselves could get extra services and grow. And as his health was declining, he participated in yet another multi-year parking study, serving as the voice of the small business owner. 

On that project, he worried out loud that we were making a mistake in creating a parking department rather than an independent parking authority — how would the interests of government not dominate the needs of customers?  Though the votes weren’t there to create an authority, he wasn’t dissuaded from arguing for what he thought would be right for the city. 

Many years ago, after a night of swing dancing up at Wesleyan, my spouse and I walked a darkened Main Street, taking advantage of the last hour of babysitting before we headed home. We stopped in front of the old vacant storefront where the original Amato’s toy store had been before it moved across to the JC Penney building. Wouldn’t it be the perfect place to hold dances right on Main Street? 

Could it be a place where people would come to socialize in a healthy way and learn a new skill? The next day, Mark Masselli called Vinny and asked if we could use the old store to create a community dance hall — and without hesitation, Vinny said yes, saying that he remembered how much fun it had been to go dancing when he was younger. I’m not entirely sure that we really got his permission on the name, but that’s how came about.

I came to rely on Vinny as an uncompromising voice of common sense that gained in wisdom over the years. He was our institutional memory, reciting in astounding detail every revitalization effort that has been tried in Middletown.  He was never afraid to consider new ideas, and he had the courage to speak his mind without being disagreeable. In short, he was a citizen, in the full meaning of the word.

I remember, shortly before Vinny became ill, having a chat together outside his store. He was unusually expansive that day and he talked about how there had been so many times over the years when he’d had the opportunity to move the store out of town. 

“It was foolish,” I remember him saying, “but I couldn’t do it. I couldn’t leave Main Street.” What he meant was that from a pure business perspective, and from the direction that his peers and competitors were taking, it didn’t make sense to keep the store on Main Street, where parking was a problem, where customers would have to mingle with the occasional down-and-outer on the sidewalk, and where his destiny was tied to the dwindling pool of neighboring stores rather than a shopping mall management team.  

I remember looking at him and saying that I hoped he knew that his decision to stay was the foundation of his prosperity and wasn’t a mistake at all — how many of those old competitors were still in business today? He agreed that most weren’t, but it seemed like he still felt that perhaps he’d allowed sentiment to outweigh reason in that choice. At the core, it hadn’t been a business decision at all. He gestured down Main Street and said, “I just couldn’t leave the people.”

As one of those people who gained so much from knowing Vinny Amato, I’m grateful that he didn’t listen to reason and head for the mall. Without his contributions, our Main Street would be a lesser place.  

In the years to come, I hope that those of us around the table will do credit to his example.  Let’s do our best to help business thrive, but sometimes, let’s allow our hearts to lead. 

Vinny was right — it’s the people that make our downtown unforgettable. He will long be remembered in this community, and not only because his name lights up, one letter at a time, over Main Street.

Grady Faulkner August 13, 2012 at 01:23 PM
This is a wonderful recollection and depiction of Mr. Amato. Yes, I called him Vinny; about the only elder I addressed so informally. I had great respect for him as we served on a couple of committees together. I was always impressed he took the time out for something I struggle to get average citizens to consider doing (it's an hour or two a month). As a person who looks at task at hand first, Party never entered our conversations and like you, we found ourselves in agreement many times; not so much on overall ideology, but on ground floor solutions. Vinny earned my utmost respect however for maintaining that big showcase of a store on our Main Street through thick and thin that made a statement that motivates me daily... we need to do all we can to Let our KIDS be KIDS.
L C August 13, 2012 at 02:38 PM
Very sad! He was a Main Street icon. I remember taking my sons there to check out the toys. They loved to watch the trains. Sometimes my Father would come with the boys and watch the train also. I loved the art supplies he kept in stock. His was a toy store like no other. Rest in peace Mr. Amato.
Lynn Agnew August 13, 2012 at 06:55 PM
When I was 19 years old, and attending Middlesex Community College, I walked into Amato's Toy Store and asked if I can have a job as an office associate. He hired me on the spot, and I worked upstairs in his original toy store with his sister, Lenore Green. Vinny was a great boss. I remember his "signature" attire. . .always decked out in a bow-tie! I loved working for him. Now, several years later, here I am, teaching dance classes in his very unique dance studio, Vinne's Jump & Jive! He may be gone, but he will never be forgotten! God Bless him and his family!
John Kilian August 13, 2012 at 07:47 PM
My children love their trips to Amato's. Their joy is part of his legacy.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »